Trisha Tinsley, Lead Trainer, Service Delivery
While I was working on my bachelor's degree, I took an addiction studies class. After learning about the most common addictive substances, our professor gave us a writing assignment to argue which substances were the most harmful. I was encouraged to consider all facets of the word “harmful.” The damage it does to the user. The harm it does to society. The harm it does to the family. After careful consideration, I concluded it was a toss-up between cigarettes and alcohol. In the end I argued that alcohol was the most harmful substance, if only due to the lack of awareness about how alcohol is a more acceptable substance of abuse.
When I was in college, cigarettes were beginning to be frowned upon socially. There was also talk in the media and government about banning smoking in public places. Increased awareness of the dangers of second hand smoke was allowing people to finally come to terms with how we are impacted by tobacco not just on a personal level. However, even in 2000, people were not as aggressive with the discussion about how we are impacted by alcohol. This is not to say that there was not information out there but it seemed like old mind sets about alcohol were still pervasive and seemed harmful to me.
April is Alcohol Awareness Month. It is the perfect time to talk about how awareness can bring about change in how we view alcohol as an addictive substance and how it affects our personal health and society.
What does “alcohol awareness” mean? It is not being aware of who shakes the best cocktail or where the best happy hour is! I want to challenge all of us to think of “awareness” as being conscious about our views and how there can be room for change. Awareness does not always mean that you become more educated about an issue. A large part of awareness is being in tune with your thoughts and feelings about an issue...This is a perfect month to check our perceptions about alcohol.
This year for Alcohol Awareness Month the Center for Disease Control (CDC) is focusing on binge drinking, especially on the harmful effects it has on women. According to the CDC, binge drinking is considered having four or more drinks on one occasion for women and five or more drinks for men. Binge drinking was a perfect issue for me to use to begin to test people’s perceptions. Due to limited time and resources I conducted an informal poll on a sample of people. I posed two scenarios to my husband, two coworkers, three acquaintances at a party, my neighbor, a woman on the bus, a friend of my husband, a yoga teacher at my gym and, of course, my mother. Not entirely a fully baked study, but the findings were interesting nonetheless.
Consider two scenarios:
Imagine a woman (Woman A) at an after-work get-together where she is hanging out with her friends. She does four shots of liquor with her friends, all within an hour and a half.
Now imagine another woman (Woman B) who is across the street from Woman A at a convention center, at a four hour-long event, sipping slowly on a glass of wine while mingling. She has about four and half glasses during the whole event.
I asked people what they thought about these scenarios. Most people couldn't get over the fact that Woman A had four shots of liquor, frowning and asking, “Is it even safe to have that many drinks in that amount of time?” I inquired, “What do you think about our lady wine drinker?” and was met with very little thoughts of concern. Then I informed my informal survey-takers that, clinically, both of these women are considered to be displaying binge drinker behavior. This puzzled my participants. Most of the people said that Woman A was an alcoholic and could be in danger, which may or may not be true. But what was revealing to me was that they did not think the Woman B was at risk at all. They perceived that she was drinking moderately; it never occurred to them that she may or may not be abusing alcohol. I informed them that drinking in moderation is considered to be having one drink a day. I still found it hard to make my point that the second woman was not drinking moderately, even to the non-drinkers I was polling.
I topped off my research by asking, “Is drinking alcohol as harmful as smoking cigarettes?” Every person said no.
I then asked, “Is having one cigarette a day the same as one drink a day?”Every person said no. They all said one cigarette a day was worse than one drink a day.
Lastly I asked, “Consider a person who smokes one cigarette per day and one person who has one drink per day. Does it cost the same to drink as it does to smoke?"
This is a question that even stumped me. But after doing math with a couple of people, we concluded that a drink can be anywhere from $2.00 to $10.00 in the state of Washington. A pack of cigarettes in the State of Washington is around $9.00. There are 20 cigarettes in a pack. $9.00 divided by 20 is .45 cents a day. Wait just a second. Not considering anything else beside the pure cost, drinking alcohol is more expensive than smoking cigarettes? This floored most of the people I talked to.
Of course, the conversation was not to encourage people to stereotype women and alcohol or to have people leave thinking smoking is a cheaper or healthier habit. The main point was to open up a dialogue on society’s preconceptions of alcohol and offer alternative ways of thinking about it – that alcohol, like tobacco, is a substance of abuse.
I help people quit smoking for a living – I help them make healthier decisions every day. As a Quit Coach® and now as a Quit Coach® trainer I have remain committed to bringing awareness of the importance of behavior change – and why drinking alcohol deserves just as much attention as smoking.
In 2006 Trisha called into the Washington State Quit Line and talked with a Quit Coach® who helped her quit smoking. After successfully quitting tobacco, she aspired to become a Quit Coach for the Quit For Life® Program and began working for Alere Wellbeing in 2009. She now works as a trainer helping Quit Coaches to work with participants who call into the Quit For Life® Program and is an active member of the Alere Wellbeing Employee Advisory Board.
Learn about the Quit For Life® Program
Read more stories from current and former Quit Coaches